In my book Truth to be told: a book on Truth vs. Reality in photography, I discuss agreements as an integral part of how we shape our reality. It can be difficult to grasp the idea that everything we take for granted is nothing but – agreements made by many people. This goes for how we celebrate Christmas to how we raise our children, to what laws our country is ruled by, which side of the road we drive our cars, how we greet each other, how we form our relationships, the importance we put on sexuality, et cetera.
Photography is no exception. We have the technique, but the rest is nothing but agreements. What we consider “good” quality in photography, what we see as rookie mistakes, what lacks quality, how we put b/w photography against colour photography (and the other way around), and so on, are agreements made by people with experience of photography – and art.
Now, all these things are as much philosophy as they are theory. If you read the book, you’ll remember that reality does not necessarily equal truth for the reasons I mentioned above – agreements on how reality functions. For me personally, I’ve made a point to live by this to the best of my ability.
This means I accept differences in people even when I disagree with another individual, which may sound like a given – but not everyone is capable of this. It takes practice to understand and accept differences on such a scale.
Recently, as a new member of a digital platform for sharing photography, I’ve been amusing myself by judging other members’ work as a part of their curating process. It’s loads of fun since I get to see many photographs of various types and quality.
And see, that’s the thing.
As someone who has just joined, I have a different perspective from those who’ve been involved in this process for a long time. And to me, this is a platform with a rather strong agreement about what quality is and what it should look like.
This is where it gets interesting to me. And, quite frankly, equally annoying.
Now, this is not a new phenomenon. Any specific type of photography has its own set of rules, of criteria for what is considered good quality. When I worked as a portrait photographer, professional portraits were (by us) considered more professional and often “better” than almost any other style of portrait.
Examples of this can be photojournalism, wedding photography, commercial photography, fashion photography, landscape photography, street photography, architectural photography, art photography – et cetera, et cetera. But we also have the agreed-upon culture of photo clubs, photography courses, photo competitions – and many other paths. Each and every one of these has very clear agreements on what good quality photography should look like – and they do differ from each other. Sometimes, they even differ between countries.
Agreements go very, very far. Much further than is easy to grasp and hold on to. I am quite used to the idea, yet even I sometimes find it hard to understand how far these agreements reach.
Now, let’s turn our attention to the entire business of judging photography in terms of quality.
If we think of the process of judging any photograph as an agreement on what quality is, we need to think at least one step further. We build our own agreement of what quality is, based on what we know about photography. If we learned to photograph from someone in photojournalism, we’re likely to use whatever agreements can be found in that area when judging photographic quality. If, instead, we learned photography from other members in a photo club, we probably consider quality through those spectacles.
Regardless of how we learned our craft, most of us were probably taught a certain set of rules – especially composition. These rules, too, are a set of agreements. At some point in time, someone decided that the rule of thirds is the way to go, to position objects in a painting. Once photography entered the scene, it adopted the rule of thirds, and other composition rules.
No wonder most of us judge quality in photography based on these composition rules.
Obviously, composition rules are only one of the agreements we judge when looking at a photograph. Other aspects often considered are how the photographer treats light, how technically skilled s/he is, how different parts of the photograph work together (composition + light + technique + whatever else the viewer finds important), et cetera.
What I find important for anyone who looks at a photograph to remember is that how we judge said photograph is built not only on composition rules, light, technique et cetera, but also on our own understanding of these things. It’s easy to get stuck in our own perception of reality, and difficult to understand how large our own part is in how we see the world and everything in it.
One good example of this phenomenon is this: put two photographers in the same location, and they’ll come up with completely different photographs – because they are different people with different skill sets, knowledge, understanding, world view, et cetera.
But the same goes for two people viewing the same photograph. They’re unlikely to see it the same way. One of them might think of it as high quality, while the other gets bored just by a glance. Who’s right? And can it be true that the photograph is both high quality and boring?
And this is exactly where things do get tricky. For me personally, I find it extremely important to understand, admit and accept that a photograph can be considered “good” by other people, even if I myself don’t like it. There is, after all, a difference between personal taste and qualities in a photograph that are held in high regard by others.
Both of these things can be true at the same time. And sometimes, it is a very good idea to remember that. And to ask oneself what agreements form the base of our own opinions about the photograph we’re looking at.
/Malinka